Rachael Denhollander posted that she will be speaking at an event that is titled "Can we reconcile Justice and Forgiveness" – I look forward to seeing what she has to say, hopefully it will be recorded and posted on YouTube.

I would like to take a stab at that talk.

First of all, are the definitions even similar? Can you find a common denominator?

Justice -  the process or result of using laws to fairly judge and punish crimes and criminals.

 Forgiveness – the action or process of forgiving or being forgiven. Synonyms -pardon, absolution, exoneration, remission, dispensation, mercy.

Justice is about fair judgement and punishment

Forgiveness is about exoneration and mercy; to pardon the behavior.

I do not see a common denominator; a meeting place to begin.

The church wants to pardon without a trial.

Yet, as I wrote that, often sexual assault cases rarely are tried, so perhaps they both are in the business of pardoning.

I am hopeful that the more victims speak up and come forth – we become a force to be reckoned with. 

It will be interesting to see if Rachael is trying to find a way for the religious folk to become educated about justice over forgiveness or in what direction she will go.

The only way I can see forgiveness is to accept that the past cannot be changed; to recognize the crime and criminal. And sadly, the courts in the land are often used to pardon the criminals in sexual abuse crimes. For it is a he said, she said.  And, the victims are often judged more harshly than the perpetrators.

Both sides, in my opinion, need to reconcile in what is a better way to address victims, and to stop the long life of pedophiles.

This reminds me of seeing if there was a common denominator between a father and a pedophile.  I haven't found one yet.

So can we reconcile Justice and Forgiveness?

IMG_4471 Rachael Denhollander, the first woman to speak publicly and file a police report against the most prolific pedophile in sport's history, Larry Nassar.

Comments

4 responses to “”

  1. Judy Avatar
    Judy

    Fascinating, as I am dealing with this in my own life. All we are taught is we must forgive. God forgives us. Certainly I don’t believe in revenge- I am a peacemonger. Yet- I have been deeply wronged , had my reputation trashed over and over, yet not once has anybody said- I am sorry. Not once. For years I have overlooked that and gone on as if nothing hurt or happened. Now- I have decided to start cutting people out of my life when they contribute to the untruth. But—- I feel guilty about it. They wronged me– they have never said sorry – and I feel guilty for leaving . I have forgiven- but the ingrained upbringing of my Catholic faith- has me feeling guilty for trying to salvage my own life. God expects us to be sorry— so why can’t we expect those who deeply wronged us to be sorry …. Or if they will not say sorry- left behind…

    Like

  2. I M Perfect Avatar

    Judy, the definition of forgiveness being that the past can be no different, allows us to be with reality. We can understand why things may have happened, the state of mind the other was in, but that doesn’t mean we have to wipe it away or pardon the action. I believe that we can ‘forgive’ by being at peace with what happened, learn from it and move on. Making better choices as to who we want in our lives or not.
    I wish you peace with your boundaries and letting the guilt go.
    I understand, for awhile I too felt guilty for taking care of myself and putting up boundaries.
    Self-Love requires us to love ourselves enough to walk away.
    Oh, and I heard there is guilt and then “Catholic Guilt” which I take is double!

    Like

  3. Ann Avatar
    Ann

    I can tell you that the “Catholic Guilt” I was brought up with is very strong stuff! Women are not powerful in the Catholic church. Women do a lot of work, make things happen and get lip service for being the center of the home—the heart of the home—doing God’s work. Thinking for yourself and caring for yourself——hum——I was taught those were just selfish things to do. Yup—Catholic Guilt is some big kind of guilt. I was taught to follow the rules, obey adults, never have any opinion which might annoy or upset others, never question authority, and never, ever bring shame to my family (or the church.)

    Like

  4. I M Perfect Avatar

    Ann, it is amazing how we can be taught to feel the extra guilt by just being ourselves and being self-loving. And, that our life mission should be to enhance the family and/or religion. How dare we deviate from our mother’s path.
    You are doing remarkable in letting go of much that was ingrained in you – becoming a freer self.

    Like

Leave a comment