Point of Conversation

Martha Beck writes (In Leaving the Saints) about the way she was taught to communicate in the Mormon Church, “through continuous indirect communication, I learned that a good Mormon girl doesn’t travel in the dimension of direct communication.”

This is how I believe most of us are taught and then call people who do talk directly and succinctly… bold, brash, cold and even bitter.

 Direct communication is scary after talking indirectly and around most sensitive issues, to just say what it is you need to say… feels terrifying.

What I know is that there are reasons we are taught indirectness in our speaking. We are told either by words or actions ‘not to go there’ and we don’t, we learn to talk in a pretend roundabout way.

We say things we don’t mean or feel…and instead say things that are not true…out of fear of getting in trouble if we don’t. Mostly we are taught to shut off our feelings and not to be so sassy and say what is on our minds. We are taught that indirect conversations are best for all concerned, it isn’t good to go to the heart of any issue.

What I know for sure, is that I went along with the indirect conversations in my home and it costs me greatly in the end.

Now, direct open frank conversations are the only ones I care to engage in, the others seem like disconnected words. Words that are not attached to the person or their truths.

I had lived for years believing that words alone were powerful that they had this great impact upon the land, until I learned that unless words are with reality and truth, they are simply just words…meaningless.

Minus meaning or meaning less than what needs to be said.

There is no difference between what I say and what I do, they match.

In the past, what I felt and what I said were worlds apart, like the polar opposites in life. I never felt that I could actually say what I feel, let alone act according to my feelings. I was taught to act against my feelings for the sake and happiness of others, out of love.

If you love someone ‘you spare them your true feelings’ is the gist of what I was taught.

And now I have learned if you love someone they above all deserve your truth.

In the end it boils down to you either have a direct meaningful relationship or you have an indirect one.

Indirect, do you care to guess its meaning? “Indirect, diverging from the direct course, roundabout. Not proceeding straight and to the point or object.”

What I have learned in the past six years is that very few speak directly to the point…most are speaking in roundabout ways, they are trying to skirt the mountain of truths, to spare their feelings and the feelings of others.

In fact, when speaking indirectly you will avoid feelings and miss the point of the conversation. 

 

Comments

3 responses to “Point of Conversation”

  1. amy byrne Avatar
    amy byrne

    I love this post!! I am, for the most part, a pretty passive person. I still sometimes wear my heart on my sleeve or even get a little feisty when I let things build up too much. I’m still trying to find a happy medium. Part of the reason I think I have become so passive is that I started looking at the things people say as more about them, and my reaction about me. So I like to stay quiet and ponder why I’m reacting in whatever way I am. The downside is that a lot of times i should speak up a lot sooner than I do! I also think it comes from the way I was raised..to be a good girl, not to rock the boat.
    I was just having a similar conversation with one of my ‘regulars’ at work. He is so critical and one of those people who “can dish it, but can’t take it” well, I’m a feeling a little sick and so I tend to get a little crabby when I am! He was telling me how he is so sick of how you can’t say what you think because people will get offended. I finally told him,” as much as you want people to accept your “offensive” words, you should accept their “offended” reactions!!” I mean, I get his point. But he goes about things in a way that are so confrontational and righteous! This is where my problem lies..I have a hard time with people like that. (I have a few close to me in my life) I definitely struggle with trying not to get sucked into an argument that will be a battle of who is right, while being able to have my own opinion or like you have said ‘my truth’. I tend to let emotion get the best of me instead of just hearing their words..and saying mine. I love what you said about “direct open, frank conversations are the only ones I care to engage in” I agree, it feels much better. Even when I don’t necessarily like what they are saying! At least I know just a little bit more about them or how they view things and/or me. So thank you for this post, it has given me great insight and a lot to think about…and anything else you may have to add is much appreciated! 🙂

    Like

  2. Karyn Avatar
    Karyn

    Great post, Beth! And what I have found is that people don’t like direct conversation, they would rather the other — say what others want to hear and you are wonderful. Tell the truth and say what is real, and you are “crushing their spirit”! I just finished Martha Beck’s book, great read!

    Like

  3. I M Perfect Avatar

    Thanks girls for your comments. I will write further in the next post. I enjoy feedback…it makes a conversation.

    Like

Leave a comment